GDG adapted 10 recommendations. Five of them relate to adrenaline as a first line for anaphylaxis treatments, adrenaline timing, dosage, method of administration, and subsequent usage in refractory cases. The other 5 recommendations focused on the role of potential adjuvant therapies (i.e., intravenous fluid, antihistamine, corticosteroids, and beta2 agonist) in addition to patients' disposition from ED. The guideline recommends against using antihistamines and corticosteroids as part of the initial therapy.
The intravenous (IV) route is not recommended for initial management of anaphylaxis, except by senior physicians who hold the privilege of using IV adrenaline. Also, the privilege of using IV adrenaline infusion to treat refractory anaphylaxis should be available for the treating physician. Although GDG advised against using antihistamines or corticosteroids as part of the initial anaphylaxis treatment, antihistamines could be used to manage skin manifestations, and corticosteroids could be given with IV crystalloids in case of hemodynamic instability and in refractory anaphylaxis, provided that their administration is not delaying adrenaline administration.
The GDG does not recommend fast-track discharge (after 2 h of observation from the resolution of anaphylaxis). Most of the Egyptian patients do not have access to adrenaline auto-injectors to be safely discharged on them. Also, adequate supervision following discharge is not guaranteed. Also, we are not sure about adequate medical supervision following discharge. Key research questions, recommendations, a summary of the evidence, and remarks related to the implementation are summarized in Table 2.
Table 2, Key research questions, recommendations, a summary of the evidence, and remarks related to the implementation
|
The question |
The recommendation |
Summary of evidence |
Remarks |
1. |
Is adrenaline effective for the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We recommend adrenaline as the first line
treatment for anaphylaxis in ED |
There is little doubt that sufficient levels of adrenaline lead to the resolution of symptoms, while delayed administration can lead to prolonged reactions, hypotension, and fatal outcomes 13 14. |
A clear definition of anaphylaxis should be provided and demonstrated through the ABCDE approach (see Annex 2,3), to discriminate it from allergic skin reaction which is not an emergency. |
2. |
What is the optimal timing of adrenaline in the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We recommend that adrenaline should be
administered early once symptoms of anaphylaxis have been recognized or
suspected |
Although there is a lack of high-certainty evidence to differentiate the effect of early versus delayed administration of adrenaline on clinical outcomes, it is reasonable to recommend administering adrenaline as soon as symptoms of anaphylaxis appear 7 13.
|
It seems reasonable to ensure the availability of adrenaline in ED to be given as soon as features of anaphylaxis are apparent. |
3. |
What is the optimal route of adrenaline to treat anaphylaxis? |
The intramuscular (IM) route is recommended
for initial adrenaline treatment for anaphylaxis |
There are currently no trials comparing the effectiveness of different ways of administering adrenaline to patients during anaphylaxis. The use of IM adrenaline as the initial treatment for anaphylaxis due to its favourable safety profile, especially for patients with cardiovascular issues 15. |
The IV route is not recommended for initial management of anaphylaxis, except by those skilled and experienced in its use.
|
4. |
What is the optimal dose of intramuscular adrenaline in the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We recommend IM adrenaline dosage listed according to age (strong recommendation, low certainty evidence)
|
The dosing regimen listed has been proven safe and effective in clinical practice for over 20 years. International guidelines recommend a dose of 0.01 mg/kg (maximum 500 micrograms) for children, which should be titrated to achieve a clinical response. Several guidelines also recommend simplifying the dosing schedule based on age categories, making it safer and more practical for emergency use by simplifying the preparation and injection process 1 16 17.
. |
Table with doses and equivalent ml should be available in ED. Adults: 500 ug (0.5 mg) IM (0.5 mL of 1 mg/ml [1:1000]) Children >12 years: Children 6-12 years: Children 6 months-6 years: 150 micrograms IM (0.15ml) Children <6 months: 100-150 micrograms IM (0.1 0.15 mL) |
5. |
Is adrenaline effective in the treatment of anaphylaxis reactions refractory to initial treatment with adrenaline? |
We recommend that: 2- Low dose intravenous (IV) adrenaline infusions appear to be effective and safe to treat refractory anaphylaxis.
very low certainty evidence). |
The absorption of adrenaline following intramuscular injection follows a biphasic profile, with the initial peak occurring within 5-10 minutes 18. Therefore, IM adrenaline should be repeated every 5-15 min where features of anaphylaxis persist 15. The rationale for waiting longer than 5 min when symptoms have failed to respond to adrenaline is unclear. Low-dose adrenaline infusions are effective in case series of human anaphylaxis 19 20 and are included as the treatment of choice for refractory anaphylaxis in national guidelines in Australia for the acute management of anaphylaxis; 2024 21. |
Where respiratory and/or cardiovascular features of anaphylaxis persist despite 2 appropriate doses of adrenaline (administered by IM or IV route), urgent expert help (e.g. from experienced critical care clinicians) should be sleeked to establish an intravenous adrenaline infusion to treat refractory anaphylaxis. Complications due to adrenaline occur regardless of route but are more common after IV administration. |
6. |
Are intravenous fluids effective as an adjuvant treatment for anaphylaxis? |
In case of anaphylaxis with haemodynamic
instability, IV crystalloid fluids should be given. |
Crystalloid infusion was more effective in restoring venous return when compared to a single dose of IM adrenaline 22. |
IV access should be obtained as early as possible, as a single bolus of IV crystalloid can be used in refractory anaphylaxis. |
7. |
Are antihistamines effective in the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We advise against using antihistamines as
part of the initial emergency treatment for anaphylaxis. |
Antihistamines are not to be utilized in the treatment of respiratory or cardiovascular symptoms associated with anaphylaxis. Their application should not impede the timely administration of adrenaline and intravenous fluids required to address such symptoms 1 17 21. |
We suggest antihistamines are used to treat skin symptoms which often occur as part of allergic reactions without delaying timely and appropriate use of adrenaline to treat anaphylaxis |
8. |
Are corticosteroids effective in the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We advise against using corticosteroids as
part of initial emergency treatment for anaphylaxis |
Corticosteroids increased the admission rate in the intensive care units and Hospital in a Canadian Emergency Department Anaphylaxis Cohort 23. Also, corticosteroids may postpone the use of adrenaline which is life saving 24. |
Corticosteroids could be included in the management of refractory anaphylaxis and shock. |
9. |
Are inhaled beta-2 agonists effective in the treatment of anaphylaxis? |
We suggest that inhaled beta2 agonist can only be used as an adjunct treatment
to adrenalin in the presence of wheezing for anaphylaxis
|
Short-acting beta-2 agonists (inhaled through a nebulizer or spacer) can be used to relieve lower respiratory symptoms and anaphylaxis, such as wheezing and coughing 25. But it should not be used instead of adrenaline as a first line of treatment for anaphylaxis 21. |
Considering bronchial asthma as an important differential diagnosis of acute onset dyspnea and wheezes.
|
10. |
How long should patients be observed in hospital following anaphylaxis? |
We recommend, minimum 6 hours observation after resolution of symptoms for all patients. Observation for at least 12 hours after the symptoms have resolved should be ensured in the following cases: - A severe reaction that necessitated more than 2 doses of adrenaline. - Patients with severe asthma or those who experienced severe respiratory compromise during the reaction. - Possibility of continued absorption of allergen, such as with slow-release medications. - Patients who present late at night or may not be able to respond to any deterioration. - Patients in areas where access to
emergency care is difficult. |
The optimal duration of observation following anaphylaxis is unknown. We suggest using a risk-stratified approach for discharging patients after anaphylaxis 24 26 . |
The rapid discharge of patients within 2-6 hours after anaphylaxis symptoms have been resolved is not considered a safe approach. However, relatively early discharge of stable patients or arranging for safe transfer to another hospital should be considered in the event of limited capacity at busy ED and small hospitals during a medical crisis. |
Anaphylaxis is a severe, life-threatening, multisystem hypersensitivity reaction that affects multiple systems. The distribution of anaphylaxis varies based on age, gender, race, geographical location, and socioeconomic status of the individuals involved; therefore, describing the epidemiology of anaphylaxis in developing countries is very crucial 27. The incidence of anaphylaxis is often underestimated in various studies due to difficulties in recognizing it and variations in diagnostic criteria among different studies and countries 28. Furthermore, the underestimation of anaphylaxis diagnosis is more pronounced in developing countries, and when diagnosed, proper management is sometimes lacking 29.
The overall prognosis for anaphylaxis is generally good. Injecting adrenaline early in the case of anaphylaxis (i.e., before arriving at the emergency department) can substantially reduce the chances of being admitted to the hospital. On the other hand, delayed administration of adrenaline has been linked to numerous cases of anaphylaxis-related fatalities in a large series of cases 30. The impact of the lack of auto-injectable devices that deliver adrenaline in the pre-hospital phase on anaphylaxis prognosis is not well studied. Cost-effectiveness analysis to study the impact of incorporating adrenaline auto- injectable adrenaline devices in the Egyptian Healthcare system should be conducted.
Guidelines for both adults and children stress the importance of prompt diagnosis for optimal treatment 31. Mistakes in diagnosing anaphylaxis can happen due to the limited time available for diagnosis, the stressful environment of the emergency room, incomplete clinical features in early anaphylaxis, and the lack of useful laboratory markers. Sensitive and specific biomarkers for anaphylaxis diagnosis will reduce its misdiagnosis 32.
A simplified universal anaphylaxis guideline dedicated to recognizing, diagnosing, and risk stratification of this condition is still unmet (see annex 3)33. Future implementation research is necessary to minimize discrepancies between guidelines and elucidate reasons for differences 34.
Clinical indicators for recommendations monitoring are needed to ensure achieving the impact of guidelines (Table 3).
Table 3: Clinical indicators for recommendations
Recommendation |
Clinical indicators |
Adrenaline as the first line treatment for anaphylaxis. |
100 % of patient presented with anaphylaxis shock should be treated with adrenaline. |
Adrenaline should be administered early once symptoms of anaphylaxis have been recognized or suspected. |
Percentage of experiencing anaphylaxis who are promptly treated with adrenaline. |
The IM route is recommended for initial adrenaline treatment. |
Percentage of patients treated with adrenaline in ED by appropriate route. |
IM adrenaline dosage listed according to age |
100 % of patients prescribed adrenaline in treatment anaphylaxis should be for the correct dose |
Subsequent doses of adrenaline, titrated to clinical response, in patients whose symptoms are refractory |
Percentage of patients with anaphylaxis who received adrenaline 2nd dose due to refractory reaction after initial dose of adrenaline |
IV crystalloid for treating anaphylaxis with haemodynamic instability |
Percentage of patients with anaphylaxis who received IV fluid (bolus and maintenance) |
Antihistamines shouldn’t be the initial emergency treatment for anaphylaxis |
Percentage of patients with anaphylaxis who administrated antihistamines prior to adrenaline |
Corticosteroids shouldn’t be the initial emergency treatment for anaphylaxis |
Percentage of patients with anaphylaxis who administrated corticosteroids prior to adrenaline |
Inhaled beta2 agonist as an adjunct treatment to adrenaline in the presence of wheezing for anaphylaxis |
Percentage of patients with lower respiratory symptoms in the context of anaphylaxis inhaled beta-2 agonists |
Minimum 6- 12 hours observation after resolution of symptoms of anaphylaxis according to the associated risk |
Percentage of patients with an acute
episode of anaphylaxis are observed in hospital for duration less than 6
hours. |